Well... For one my view of the world differs a lot. The term "girl of my dreams" could not possibly apply to only one single woman out of billions for me. There are many girls out there that might deserve that title.
Of course, it depends also in what time I would have gotten into that kind of story. If I had been still a young teenager, I'm not sure how I would have handled it. If it was right now, I know that I would have probably done the same thing. That is, I probably wouldn't have agreed to the math tutoring before 5 in the first place, no matter how much of a crush I had on Haley (even while I was still a teenager and my view of the world was different).