I like what you're doing with the general layout. It's very readable.
I would agree that the default icons don't match the aesthetic style of the menu background or characters you've chosen, but I understand they may just be placeholders.
I don't really a have a problem with light/"parchment" colored backgrounds personally, but most people tend to prefer darker, more "solid" colored backgrounds, it seems. Are you planning on allowing the user to change the menu skin? If so, you may want to consider giving players the option to check through them and pick one out early in the game.