Everyone's formulated to their own opinion. I for one, personally prefer Kirby Super Star over Morrowind for example. Though it is hard for me to choose a favorite. Though Dio, Morrowind isn't that old...o.o It's just about 6 years, not that long.
So has anyone ever heard of Shadowgate? It's one of those generic Point-and-click, but it's extremely fun, especially if you die a lot. If you never heard of Shadowgate, it's been released for the NES, Mac, PC, and recently some Mobile and Pocket PCs. Here's four screenshots: