Signature and Avatar Ratings

Started by tSwitch, February 19, 2009, 08:57:00 am

Previous topic - Next topic

tSwitch

Stolen from RMRK cuz it's fun. (if you think this should hit forum games idk, it works along with posting desktops and pictures, I suppose, it's just for avs and sigs)

you rate the avatar/sig of the person above you from 0 to 10.
generally you give a reason why.

and try to not reply if you rated the person already and they haven't changed yet.
and now for mine:

0/10 because you don't exist


FCF3a A+ C- D H- M P+ R T W- Z- Sf RLCT a cmn+++ d++ e++ f h+++ iw+++ j+ p sf+
Follow my project: MBlok | Find me on: tSwitch.us | Twitter | Tumblr

Tazero



If you were a fish...

Landith

6/10 because it looks like it's just advertisement/achievements but it's still Super Smash Bros. :)

Starrodkirby86

8.25/10

Oh my, so exact. :o

Your signature is terrific and is one of my favorite Landith signatures to date, but your avatar doesn't fit you so well. It's a usual avatar that I see anyway, but it's amusing nonetheless.

What's osu!? It's a rhythm game. Thought I should have a signature with a working rank. ;P It's now clickable!
Still Aqua's biggest fan (Or am I?).




Diokatsu

7.5/10

Great use of the horizontal line. Nice and stylish, sleek even. My low ratings are not what they seem. 7 means it's quite, quite good.

Chaze007

Always I Wanna Be With You! Make Believe With You!

G_G

SIG   5/10 For making your sign look exactly like blizz's.
AVVIE Neat avvie though so 7/10

Chaze007

6/10 nice 3d sig, btw it is blizz's lol.
Always I Wanna Be With You! Make Believe With You!

Valcos

"We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars."
-Oscar De La Hoya

Chaze007

Always I Wanna Be With You! Make Believe With You!

wolfi--

For some reason, when I change my ava on any other forum, it changes here too..
but the sig doesn't
So i manually do it ;-;



Chase:
Avatar: 8/10, looks cool. Nice logo.
Sig:  7/10 Nice you put the rules on the sig, it's original. The top thing is too big tho ;-;

tSwitch

Quote from: wolfi-- on February 20, 2009, 03:59:53 am
:wurfy:


I give you a 10/10 on both because team fortress 2 rocks and the spy is badass.

Quote from: MetaKnight on February 19, 2009, 04:36:57 pm
8/10 cause your sig isnt fin


it is finished, it's just right justified.


FCF3a A+ C- D H- M P+ R T W- Z- Sf RLCT a cmn+++ d++ e++ f h+++ iw+++ j+ p sf+
Follow my project: MBlok | Find me on: tSwitch.us | Twitter | Tumblr

Tazero



If you were a fish...

Diokatsu

7/10 Organized, but that spare spoiler tag drags it down. Not phenomenal.

Landith

More advertisements, but it flows smoothly together. Good quote, nice sig pic in the spoiler.

Overall -- 8/10

Starrodkirby86

Nice lady. I wonder where she came from. But I really can't put my finger on how this really fits you too much, but regardless it's great.

Erm, I suppose it's a 8.75/10 here, while the signature would still get high marks, a 9/10 I reckon.

What's osu!? It's a rhythm game. Thought I should have a signature with a working rank. ;P It's now clickable!
Still Aqua's biggest fan (Or am I?).




Landith

Off Topic: ShowHide
Actually that won't be my avatar, I was just messing around with renders getting a good feel in photoshop.


Nice avatar, fits you well. Nice use of the Horizontal rule and because it has osu! it's perfect.
Avvie -- 9.5/10
Sig -- 8.76/10 :V:
Overall -- 9.25/10

Reno-s--Joker

I must say I missed the cool character person you had before but...

Avvie :: 9/10
Sig :: also 9/10 ^-^

Some really nice fonts and effects there. <3

Chaze007

Always I Wanna Be With You! Make Believe With You!

Starrodkirby86

-9000/10 because of your unfortunate attitude of flaming but it's not really flaming as you were joking, despite the fact it definitely didn't sound like you were joking.

(In reality, I probably would have given it a 7.95/10 or something...)

What's osu!? It's a rhythm game. Thought I should have a signature with a working rank. ;P It's now clickable!
Still Aqua's biggest fan (Or am I?).




Calintz

I am going to give you an outlandish 10/10 Starrodkirby.

There is just something about that Avatar that makes me happy, Lol. I used to be a total anime fan, and the style of art portrayed in that Avatar replicates the only style that I could become truly immersed into as a kid.

That aside, the art is high quality, and the vertical symmetry is flawless.

CP members...you are looking at avatar perfection!!

Blizzard

OMG, I POSTED HERE!

9/10 for avatar and signature.
They are very clean, properly sized and they fit with each other. Good job. :) The small draw back was the small "Calintz16438" in the avatar which can be hardly read and is unecessary and the letters in the sig saying "Calintz16438" that were a bit too thin and a bit hard to make out.
Check out Daygames and our games:

King of Booze 2      King of Booze: Never Ever
Drinking Game for Android      Never have I ever for Android
Drinking Game for iOS      Never have I ever for iOS


Quote from: winkioI do not speak to bricks, either as individuals or in wall form.

Quote from: Barney StinsonWhen I get sad, I stop being sad and be awesome instead. True story.

Tazero



If you were a fish...

Chaze007

Always I Wanna Be With You! Make Believe With You!

Tazero



If you were a fish...

Calintz

8/10
Love the little guy, but hate that he is not rendered properly

Reno-s--Joker

Avvie: 8/10 - solely because I'm attracted to brighter colours ^-^;
Sig: 9/10 - you chose a good section to put in the userbar, and it has a really nice balance of both colours and lines! :D

Calintz

7/10

It is pretty clean, but if you are gonna have something pop over a border, you really want all of that to be able to be seen, but it cuts off. Pop outs are not a good choice of design for an avatar.

Everything else is pretty clean and good.

Blizzard

Check out Daygames and our games:

King of Booze 2      King of Booze: Never Ever
Drinking Game for Android      Never have I ever for Android
Drinking Game for iOS      Never have I ever for iOS


Quote from: winkioI do not speak to bricks, either as individuals or in wall form.

Quote from: Barney StinsonWhen I get sad, I stop being sad and be awesome instead. True story.

Fantasist

Sig: Sorry, but 7. It's just a picture cropped from the title and doesn't look like the picture is made for a sig. Like Calintz's.
Avtar: Okay, this is how it goes.
Avatar alone: 2/10 (It's kinda sick)
Avatar with the custom text: 10000000/10 (I still can't help laughing when I see that XD)

Overall: 9/10
Do you like ambient/electronic music? Then you should promote a talented artist! Help out here. (I'm serious. Just listen to his work at least!)


The best of freeware reviews: Gizmo's Freeware Reviews




Hellfire Dragon

Avatar: 7.5/10, I always wondered what exactly that was meant to be actually
Sig: 5/10, it's a nice list just a little plain ya know?

Fantasist

Sig: 6/10 Could do with some contrast.
Avvy: 9/10 I have that pic and I love it! But since the text is too small, you won't get the joke.
Do you like ambient/electronic music? Then you should promote a talented artist! Help out here. (I'm serious. Just listen to his work at least!)


The best of freeware reviews: Gizmo's Freeware Reviews




Landith

Avvie -- 9/10 Really nice, fits you well
Sig -- 6/10 shows all your work with RMXP and that's good
Overall -- 8/10

Diokatsu

Sig = 9/10 LOVE IT
Avvie = 7/10 The Landith is nice, but the pic is kinda funky, in a good way. Not amazing though.
Overall = 8/10 Good job, kiddo. I knew you had it in you.

King Munkey

Sig = 8/10 Alot of stuff but its not plain and i like that.
Avatar = 8/10 although for some reason the white background is very blinding to me at the moment

G_G Is my hero!
Munkey != monkey
Munkey > monkey

Diokatsu

Sig = 7/10 Plain, but I do love MGS
Avvie = 10/10 ...Is there anything not great about that?
Overall = 8/10 Good, good.

Pokol DaErran

Avatar: 10/10.  The image and the effects are both great and go together perfectly.
Signature: 9/10.  It's great and I would have given you a full 10, but I can't shake the feeling that there's something wrong...

So, overall, 10/10.  I'm impressed.
"...Sometimes, the impossible can become possible- if you're awesome!"
--Bolt

Tazero

7/10 pokemon = Cheap
The siggy gets 6/10 +1/10 on avvie
so 7/10


If you were a fish...

fugibo

Avvie: It reminds me of those awesome avvies with fighting sticks that I used to see, so you only get 7/10. If it weren't for nostalgia, you would receive a 8.85314.

Sig: Meh. I don't like sigs. 6/10.

Diokatsu

Avvie: 10/10
What can I say?
Sig: 8/10
It's informative. :3

Tazero

10/10 Cuz i'm happy Yay flying uniponies


If you were a fish...

legacyblade

Avie: 4/10
because that avatar really gets on my nerves. Not a fan of animated avatars.
Sig: 5/10
only text sigs would normally get something like 2/10, but the links are useful, so thus it gets bumped up 3 points.

Fallen Angel X

The avatar, I give a 6/10 because cookies beat pretzels any day. The sig I give a 6.5/10. I think its passable for sure.

How badly do I fail? :P

fugibo

note: FAX, you've obviously never eaten a proper pretzel.

Avvie:
1/2, 'cuz the colors suck and it doesn't fit you at all.

Siggie:
6/10, If it were smaller height-wise it'd be great.

Calintz

Avatar: 6/10
Great theme...Terrible quality, but I can make out what it is, so I will give it one extra point to make it 6/10.

Tazero

5/5
4/5
Do the math xD overall 4.99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999/5

I fail right?@!


If you were a fish...

fugibo

The avvie's grown on me; 7/10
Sig: Fail. 3/10. Way too much crap in it.

Chaze007

I won! 8/10..the king scares me 4/10
Always I Wanna Be With You! Make Believe With You!

Tazero



If you were a fish...

King Munkey

5/10 Avatar
7/10 Sig
The avatar is just getting annoying to me.

G_G Is my hero!
Munkey != monkey
Munkey > monkey

Punn

Ava - 2/10 - too small, bad quality, not a big fan of FF series.
Sig - 4/10 - not original...

Zylos

7/10 Avi - Nice, but a bit small.
0/10 Sig - It broke the rules. D=
6/10 Sig - Decent.




Tazero



If you were a fish...

fugibo

0/10 YOU FAIL!

Actually, 7/10, it grows evermore

Reno-s--Joker

Avvie: 1000/10
I don't get it, but medieval king dude ftw.
Sig: 0/10
You just made me lose the game! D':

Tazero

9/10
8/10
7/10
....

Overall is 9/10
avie 8/10
sig...Ehh whatever


If you were a fish...

fugibo

You befoul this thread with so many posts *snarl*

*is just posting here so he can get opinions on his replacement avvie*

Yeah, new avvie: 6/10. Those are annoying :(

Fallen Angel X

The avvie gets a 6/10. I kinda get it =\

The sig gets 8/10. I don't play the game or whatever it is. :P

Diokatsu

Sig = 10/10
AWESOME.

Avvie = 9/10
Classic FAX.

GAX

Avi gets a 9/10, I love the color and it's pretty
Signature gets more of a 8/10...sorry, it's just that I prefer SM to FFR, but the links give bonus points, along with the CP Bar + epic quote.

Here's a question for later (one of my friends brought this up): "Are we created in God's image or is the image of God our own? (is God created in our image?)"

Rule 2: ShowHide
Quote from: Rule No.2Keep your signatures at reasonable size. The pictures in your signature may altogether be no more than 200kB and take up an area of 1600px2. That means 2 pictures of 400x200 are fine, one picture of 800x200 is fine and so on. Also your pictures height must not exceed 200 pixels, width can be as big as you want as long as your pictures match the other criteria. Every signature not matching this criteria is a subject of the moderator team to remove and leave this rule as message in your signature.

fugibo

Avvie: 8/10, it fits you
Sig: 6/10, I dunn like the color so much for  a siggie

Tazero



If you were a fish...

King Munkey


G_G Is my hero!
Munkey != monkey
Munkey > monkey

Tazero

I don't like ps3 5/10
I can't see ur avie 0/10


If you were a fish...

Reno-s--Joker

Sig: 5/10 (Personally I like ones which are less tall and I am still confused about the 'more creative than logic' - although personality tests are always interesting)
Avvie: 6/10 (Good to watch once .... hurts after a while)

Landith

Batman and tons of shit, without a doubt, 9/10 for both
It's just that good

Zylos





King Munkey


G_G Is my hero!
Munkey != monkey
Munkey > monkey

Vell


Tazero

Green/Blue * 3 + sqrt of 70

yellow/girl


If you were a fish...

Diokatsu

8/10
I <3 that avatar. They entertain me so much. The picture in your signature isn't pleasing though. It's too gritty and unrefined for my taste. Change the "fuck you" to something nicer please.

King Munkey

9/10 for both
Absolutely love both the new avatar and sig.

G_G Is my hero!
Munkey != monkey
Munkey > monkey

Zylos

10/10 for the avi for <3
8/10 for the sig for being a bit cluttered. ._.




Tazero



If you were a fish...