As much as Landith LOVES his Papyrus, I would go for fonts that are original and somewhat underused for something this "epic".
It depends on how your game's atmosphere would be for which of the four insignias you would choose I suppose. Take out 4, that one isn't smooth. 3's quite plain, but a simple game has simple features!

That leaves 1 and 2. One is feel is all metallic, and if that's your theme (Which it probably is) then sure, have that. 2 is red, which makes it look pretty sweet, and since it is red (Albeit dark), it's going to be quite an attention grabber. But it'll also be considered bloody and it might be an overused aspect, at least that's how I think it.
So choose what you like.